Here’s an interesting discussion on the TMP page about Classroom Deathmatch. It seems like a lot of th visitors to The Miniatures Page had a pretty common reaction to Classroom Deathmatch and found it offensive in light of the Virginia Tech shootings. Thankfully there were plenty of people on TMP who were either familiar with Classroom Deathmatch and could explain it or understood what it was about right away. The discussion is worth reading because it raises a number of valid points and concerns. I wish I had been able to post on the TMP page, but it looks like doing so requires a paid membership. let’s talk about it here instead!
The primary concern is that the name “Classroom Deathmatch” is in bad taste and that it cashes in on the Virginia Tech shootings. Of course we had no intention of trying to benefit from these shootings. Classroom deathmatch was in development for months and months before this happened, and was released a day or so before the shootings. It’s an unfortunate coincidence, but that’s all it is. As far as the name being in bad taste, it most certainly is. That’s the point. Classroom deathmatch deals with an almost unbearable subject. Murder, betrayal, suicide and the sacrifice of friendship and love should never be easy topics, but a good role-playing game forces the players to deal with uncomfortable situations and ask really tough questions. This is what Classroom Deathmatch is all about. Pretending that the concept isn’t horrifying does a disservice to the players, to the game and to the concept.
Of course, I understand how easy it would be to hear the name and think of the Virginia Tech shootings. I get that. For anyone interested in learning more about the game, information is just a quick google search away. For the people who are ready to condemn the game based on only it’s name… well, I can’t do much about that.
But here’s the thing. Much like with Panty Explosion, if the name really offends you that much then I’m guessing that you wouldn’t want to play the game anyway. I can’t imagine someone who was really offended by the names “Classroom deathmatch” or Panty Explosion” would actually ever be interested in laying either game, no matter what they were called. that’s fine with me. Almost all games have very narrow target audiences, and few appeal to “almost everyone”. Classroom Deathmatch was made for people who wanted to play a Battle Royale type game. If that’s not what you want to play then I imagine Classroom Deathmatch is not the game for you. Which is okay. I don’t feel like I need to win over every game player.
A lot of people here about PE and Classroom Deathmatch for the first time from Steve Jackson’s e23 site, and think that Steve actually publishes the game. Not true. e23 is a store that carries digital content. They’ve decided they like Panty Explosion and classroom Deathmatch and have gone out of their way to include both games on their store and to say nice things about them. We’re extremely grateful for that! Both Panty Explosion and Classroom Deathmatch are published by Atarashi Games. You can find both games in retail stores world wide (well, Classroom Deathmatch won’t make it to stores till late this month) and on dozens of online stores, including our own Atarashi Games store.
Another common misconception is that our games are only available as PDF’s. Not true at all. Both Classroom Deathmatch and Panty Explosion were designed as print products. Although many people first come across the games on sites like e23 or DrivethruRPG, the games are widely available as perfect bound books.
Several of the TMP members may find it interesting to know that sales of Classroom Deathmatch have been poor in the US but fantastic in Japan, Italy, Australia, Korea, England, France, Sweden, Israel and Canada. I do think that a number of potential American customers were turned off by the title. This clearly hasn’t been the case for oversea customers, who have been ordering the game steadily. This does not suprise me at all. As I said before, the games release date is an unfortunate coincidence, and I think it’s unreasonable to expect an enthusiastic welcome for a product that superficially resembles a recent national tragedy. I get that. Fortunately (or unfortunately), we Americans have a short attention span. I suspect by Gencon this will all behind us and copies of Classroom deathmatch will fly off the shelf as fast as Panty explosion did last year.
But we’ll see.
Jake